Skip to main content

Best grilled cheese in New Castle, PA.

Comfort in Every Melt

Grilled Cheese Made Fresh

Grilled cheese brings together crisp, golden bread and warm, melted cheese for a satisfying bite any time of day. Enjoy it as a comforting breakfast, a quick cafe lunch, or an easy family meal. Pair your sandwich with coffee or another favorite from the menu, and savor a familiar American classic prepared fresh to order.

Grilled Cheese for Pickup or Delivery

Enjoy grilled cheese wherever mealtime takes you. Choose pickup for a convenient way to bring a freshly made sandwich home, to work, or on the go. Delivery makes it easy to enjoy a warm, cheesy meal without leaving your table. Check available ordering options and hours when you place your order, and add a coffee or another cafe favorite to complete your meal.

Our location

Map showing the location of Sims Cafe on 3310 Wilmington Rd in New Castle
Loading today's hours...